Why Did ACX Reject My Audiobook? A Chicago Recording Studio Explains
An audiobook gets rejected by ACX for one of two reasons: the audio misses one of ACX’s technical numbers, or the files break ACX’s formatting rules. Both are fixable before you ever hit submit. At my Chicago recording studio, every chapter is recorded, edited, and mastered to ACX’s requirements, so the book arrives at review already inside every number ACX checks.
The Five Numbers ACX Checks on Every File
ACX measures every file you upload, and its Quality Assurance team can send a title back if a single chapter misses. These are the numbers:
- Volume between -23dB and -18dB RMS
- Peaks no higher than -3dB
- Noise floor below -60dB RMS
- 44.1kHz MP3 at 192kbps or higher, constant bit rate
- Every file in the same channel format, all mono or all stereo
Where Audiobooks Usually Fail
Noise floor is the most common reason audiobooks get rejected, and ACX’s free Audio Lab tool doesn’t measure it. That means a book can pass every check on ACX’s own site and still come back after review. ACX measures noise floor in the silence between words, and that’s where a refrigerator, a furnace, traffic, or a computer fan shows up. Getting a spare bedroom below -60dB is hard. Getting there with a voice that still sounds natural is harder.
Inconsistent sound is the next one. ACX wants the whole book to sound like one book: the same levels, tone, noise, spacing, and pronunciation from the first chapter to the last. A chapter recorded on a different day, at a different distance from the mic, or in a different room can sound like a different narrator. Recording every session in the same room through the same chain is what keeps chapter 1 and chapter 40 matched.
Peaks are the third. A hard “p,” a laugh, or a raised voice in one line can spike past -3dB even when the rest of the chapter sits perfectly in range.
Extra sounds are the fourth. ACX specifically calls out plosives, mic pops, clicks, excessive mouth noise, and outtakes. Each chapter gets read straight through first, then we play it back and punch in fixes. We edit each chapter together in the session, playing it back at somewhere between 1.5x and 3x speed and cutting every retake, breath, and mouth sound, so nothing extra makes it to mastering.
Room tone is the last technical catch. ACX recommends 1 to 5 seconds of room tone at the beginning and end of every file, and no silence anywhere in the file can run longer than 5 seconds.
The Formatting Rules That Catch Authors Off Guard
A book can pass every audio number and still get sent back for structure. These are the rules ACX holds every title to:
- One chapter or section per file, and no file longer than 120 minutes. A longer chapter gets split, with a secondary header for continuity.
- Every file includes its section header, like “Prologue” or “Chapter 1.”
- Opening credits are their own file and state the title, author, and narrator, matching the cover art and the book’s listing exactly.
- Closing credits are their own file and signal the end. ACX suggests “You have been listening to,” followed by the title, author, and narrator, then “The End.”
- A retail sample of 5 minutes or less, taken from the audiobook itself, with no explicit material. ACX asks for the first five minutes of the book.
- File names use only standard letters and numbers, no special characters.
- The book must be narrated by a human. Unauthorized AI or text-to-speech narration isn’t allowed.
Record the credits in the same room, on the same mic, as the rest of the book. Credits recorded later somewhere else are the easiest way to break ACX’s consistency rule in the very first file a listener hears.
How I Master Audiobooks at My Chicago Recording Studio
Every narration runs through a Neumann U87 into a Neve 1073 for subtractive EQ, a 76 compressor, a second 1073 for additive EQ, and a 2A compressor. That chain is the same for every session, which is what makes a book recorded over several visits sound like it was read in one sitting.
ACX requires RMS loudness between -23dB and -18dB, true peak under -3dB, a noise floor below -60dB, and a file exported at 44.1kHz, 320kbps CBR. I record everything at 44.1kHz/24-bit and only dither down to 16-bit on final export, which keeps more headroom for mastering.
In mastering, my final limiters are set to a -3.5dB true peak ceiling. That leaves half a decibel of room under ACX’s -3dB limit, so a loud line can’t push a chapter over.
I only master audiobooks recorded here, because mastering can only work with what the recording gives it. If you already work with a mastering engineer, you can take your edited chapters to them instead.
What Recording and Mastering an Audiobook Costs in Chicago
Recording and editing run $50 an hour with a 4-hour minimum, and mastering is $150 per finished hour. A finished hour of audio covers about 7,800 to 9,000 words, and studio time usually runs 2 to 3 times the finished length to allow for retakes and editing.
A 70,000-word book comes out to about 8 to 9 finished hours. That’s roughly 16 to 27 hours of studio time, or $800 to $1,350, plus $1,170 to $1,350 for mastering, for a total of about $2,000 to $2,700. Use the audiobook calculator below to price your own book.
What Does It Cost to Record an Audiobook?
of audio
—
$150 per finished hour
Recording, editing, and mastering — ACX compliance included
The calculator estimates finished audio length at 7,800–9,000 words per finished hour — a realistic range that accounts for natural narration pace variation. Recording and editing runs 2–3× the finished hour estimate in studio time at $50/hr. Mastering is billed at $150 per finished hour. Both are broken out separately in the event you have your own mastering engineer and only need recording as a service.
Call for a Free ConsultationCheck Your Files Before You Submit
ACX has a free audio analysis tool called Audio Lab that checks finished files against its standards, but it doesn’t measure noise floor, the most common reason audiobooks get rejected. It also can’t catch editing errors or stray sounds, which ACX’s reviewers find by listening after you submit. Run every chapter through a third-party checker for noise floor, check every chapter rather than just the first, and listen to each one start to finish. I check the noise floor on every chapter with a separate checker before a book leaves the studio.
What to Bring to a First Conversation
Call me with your word count, whether you’re publishing through ACX or another platform, and the title, author, and narrator names exactly as they appear on your cover, since the credits have to match. If your book has names, places, or terms that are easy to mispronounce, bring a list. Pronunciation is one of the things ACX checks for consistency across the whole book.
Getting Started
Untold Stories Recordings is Chicago’s #1-rated and most-reviewed recording studio, with a 5.0 rating across 197+ reviews. Call the studio at 872-444-6316 to talk through your audiobook.